November 14, 2006
Punishing heroes ISN'T the way to win hearts and minds
The following is a dramatic example of how NOT to win the hearts and minds of locals.
Now, I certainly have no insight to the history of Mohammad Gulab's
life but his heroic deed, described in the article below, in saving
the life of a U. S. serviceman, overrides anything else. If this
incident, in its totality, is but a small portion of the entire panorama
in Afghanistan--and let's hope it isn't--then all is also lost there.
Gulab certainly did far, far more positive for the United States in Afghanistan than
Ahmed "Scumbag" Chalabi did for our country in Iraq. Remember Chalabi
with, "We are heroes in error...as far as we're concerned, we've been
entirely successful...our objective has been achieved...that tyrant
Saddam is gone, and the Americans are in Baghdad...what was said before
is not important."
Yes, tell that to the families of wounded, maimed and dead American
soldiers, to the soldiers themselves, to the thousands of murdered
Iraqis...
Here's Gulab's atory:
A Friend in Need
The proud Afghan risked all to save a Navy SEAL. Now, feeling abandoned, he is facing death threats.
By Ron Moreau and Sami Yousafzai
Newsweek
April 17, 2006 issue - Even with all the troubles that
followed, Mohammad Gulab says he's still glad he saved the U.S. Navy
SEAL. "I have no regrets for what I did," the 32-year-old Afghan told
NEWSWEEK recently. "I'm proud of my action." Nevertheless, he says, "I
never imagined I would pay such a price." Last June, foraging for
edible plants in the forest near his home in the Kunar-province village
of Sabray, Gulab discovered a wounded commando, the lone survivor of a
four-man squad that had been caught in a Taliban ambush. Communicating
by hand signs, Gulab brought the injured stranger home, fed and
sheltered him for two days and helped contact a U.S. rescue team to
airlift him out.
Gulab has been paying for his kindness ever since. Al Qaeda and the
Taliban dominate much of Kunar's mountainous backcountry. Death threats
soon forced Gulab to abandon his home, his possessions and even his
pickup truck. Insurgents burned down his little lumber business in
Sabray. He and his wife and their six children moved in with his
brother-in-law near the U.S. base at Asadabad, the provincial capital.
Three months ago Gulab and his brother-in-law tried going back to
Sabray. Insurgents ambushed them. Gulab was unhurt, but his
brother-in-law was shot in the chest and nearly died. The threats
persist. "You are close to death," a letter warned recently. "You are
counting your last days and nights."
Go here to read further.
Newsweek also did a followup.
With Friends Like These...
Update: An Afghan who risked all to rescue a wounded Navy SEAL finds trouble with the Talibanand the U.S. military
Newsweek Web Exclusive
By Sami Yousafzai
May 13, 2006
Death threats from the Taliban aren't Mohammad Gulab's only worry. As
reported in NEWSWEEK's April 17 issue, the Afghan villager has been
pursued by Al Qaeda's local partners ever since June 2005, when he
rescued a wounded U.S. Navy SEAL in the mountains of Kunar province,
east of Kabul. Vengeful jihadists burned down his village lumber
business and forced him and his family to flee for their lives,
abandoning their home and possessions. The Americans never delivered on
promises Gulab says they made to relocate the family to a safe place,
so they moved in with Gulab's brother-in-law near the U.S. base at the
provincial capital, Asadabad. But Gulab never expected that the
American military would target him next.
Late on Friday, April 14, the week NEWSWEEK's story appeared,
Gulab's phone rang. The caller told him to come to the U.S. base
at 11 the next morning, and Gulab barely slept that night, thinking the
Americans were going to relocate him and his family out of danger. When
he reported to the main gate on Saturday, he found a pair of U.S.
soldiers waiting for him. They checked his name and then
handcuffed and blindfolded him, hauling him off to an unlit room in a
remote corner of the base. There, he says, he was placed in a cage so
cramped that he could neither stand up nor lie down.
Hours later, two Americans and an interpreter entered the room and
began interrogating him. Most of the questions were about his life and
his family, although Gulab couldn't imagine why. He was sure his
captors knew exactly who he was, he says. They inquired about ties to
al Qaeda, a question he considered insulting. Hadn't he saved an
American commando's life? And the interrogators kept returning to the
subject of his contacts with NEWSWEEK. They had searched him and found
a NEWSWEEK reporter's business card with an Islamabad address. The
interrogators kept asking when he had been to Pakistan and where had
gone, although he told them he had not traveled to the Pakistani
capital.
Gulab says the session lasted more than an hour. It was only the first
in a series that continued until the afternoon of the fourth day. Then
the Americans told him he was free to go home. He had trouble walking
after spending so much time locked up in a cramped cage. His captors
never told him why he had been detained, he says, but before his
release, one of the interrogators offered some advice: "Stay away from
reporters. It will be in your best interest."
NEWSWEEK has repeatedly asked the U.S. military to clarify the
incident. Lt. Col. Paul Fitzpatrick, a public-affairs officer at U.S.
headquarters in Bagram, sent this reply via email: "Mr. Gulab was
detained and questioned by coalition forces and released. I can't
discuss any details of why he was questioned but it was not related to
his interview with Newsweek." The Pentagon has not responded to several
requests for comment. The Taliban and its friends are not so reticent.
After word got out that the Americans had locked up Gulab, someone left
a message affixed to the wall of his brother-in-law's house. "This is
your punishment from God in this world," the note said, "and a taste of
what you will get on the day of judgment." Gulab continues to believe
he did the right thing by saving the SEAL.
Go here to read further.
top
RSS feed
|