February 10, 2005
Jonathan Alter puts Tom DeLay into perspective
You can certainly disagree with the following Jonathan Alter
diagnosis of the depravity of Christian moralist Tom DeLay and his
deleterious effect on the current state of American political affairs.
But I call on you to dismantle it point-by-point.
Who is up to the challenge?
Use all the four (and more) letter words you want but factually de-construct Alter's thesis and documentatrion.
Tom DeLay's House of Shame
Congress has always had its share of extremists. But the DeLay era is the first time the fringe has ever been in charge.
By Jonathan Alter
Newsweek
Oct. 10, 2005 issue - A decade ago, I
paid a call on Tom DeLay in his ornate office in the Capitol. I had
heard a rumor about him that I figured could not possibly be true. The
rumor was that after the GOP took control of the House that year, DeLay
had begun keeping a little black book with the names of Washington
lobbyists who wanted to come see him. If the lobbyists were not
Republicans and contributors to his power base, they didn't get into
"the people's House." DeLay not only confirmed the story, he showed me
the book. His time was limited, DeLay explained with a genial smile.
Why should he open his door to people who were not on the team?
Thus began what historians will regard as the
single most corrupt decade in the long and colorful history of the
House of Representatives. Come on, you say. How about all those years
when congressmen accepted cash in the House chamber and then staggered
onto the floor drunk? Yes, special interests have bought off members of
Congress at least since Daniel Webster took his seat while on the
payroll of a bank. And yes, Congress over the years has seen dozens of
sex scandals and dozens of members brought low by financial
improprieties. But never before has the leadership of the House been
hijacked by a small band of extremists bent on building a ruthless
shakedown machine, lining the pockets of their richest constituents and
rolling back popular protections for ordinary people. These folks
borrow like banana republics and spend like Tip O'Neill on speed.
I have no idea if DeLay has technically broken the
law. What interests me is how this moderate, evenly divided nation came
to be ruled on at least one side of Capitol Hill by a zealot. This is a
man who calls the Environmental Protection Agency "the Gestapo of
government" and favors repealing the Clean Air Act because "it's never
been proven that air toxins are hazardous to people"; who insists
repeatedly that judges on the other side of issues "need to be
intimidated" and rejects the idea of a separation of church and state;
who claims there are no parents trying to raise families on the minimum
wage—that "fortunately, such families do not exist" (at least Newt
Gingrich was intrigued by the challenges of poverty); who once said: "A
woman can't take care of the family. It takes a man to provide
structure." I could go on all day. Congress has always had its share of
extremists. But the DeLay era is the first time the fringe has ever
been in charge.
To read the rest, go here.
top
RSS feed |