I Cogitate

Recent Posts My Best Blogs Archives Favorite Quotes Links Contact
June 21,  2005

President Bush: You're Not Now Nor Have You Ever Been One Of Us

Who would argue with the premise that President Bush has led a charmed life? Well, besides the uber GOP media manufacturers who never met a fact they couldn't distort into unreality.

Born into a wealthy, politically and socially-connected family, President Bush attended Andover, an exclusive prep school, Yale University and Harvard Business School. This despite an academic record that would be a slam dunk (although, mind you, not a George Tenet one) in preventing others from doing so.

His business dealings have been permeated not by any deft business touch but by the trifecta of the wattage his surname brings for investors, investiture into Skull and Bones and the good will and contacts developed by his father.  .

Despite his personal re-invention to appear as just another average weed-whacking Joe Rancher, a pattern of connections emerges that have aided and sustained President Bush throughout his life.

Call them financial 'safety nets' unavailable to any but the elite.

Now my egalitarian instincts and beliefs lead me to salute socio-economic ladder-climbing on the basis of personal skill and hard work but the Bush family logo is inscribed with 'use 'em if you got 'em', overlayed with a generous variation of Tennessee Williams' kindness of 'strangers.'

His push to revamp societal safety nets such as Social Security and personal bankruptcy laws, concerns that have not and will not ever effect anyone in the Bush clan, is inexplicable. Why this zeal to reduce or eliminate social 'insurances' that provide a softer landing to economic free-falling middle and lower income families?

Some suggest, with the actual ability to keep a straight face while doing so, that it is President Bush's genuine concern for the common person that is driving his domestic political agenda.  

If such were so, then wouldn't he be diligently pushing a plan to provide medical coverage for the half a million of Americans who cannot afford it? The individual 'health account' idea proposed by Bush is a broken crutch, especially to cover the cost of serious medical conditions, the illnesses that produce most personal bankruptcies..

Why add a second shiv in the back and push for new bankruptcy legislation that strictly favors campaign-contributing lending institutions?

The usually reliable smell test indicates that President Bush's domestic political maneuverings are payback to his corporate backers. For those too delicate for such an olfactory examination, simply follow the money. According to the Center For Responsive Politics and OpenSecrets.org:
"finance/credit companies contributed more than $9 million in soft money, PAC and individual contributions to federal parties and candidates during the 1999-2000 election cycle. More than two-thirds of that money went to Republicans..."
No, this 'genuine common person concern' just doesn't add up, much like the Bush federal budget in relation to what is actually in the national cash register..

Let's take a peak at George Bush through the years to better understand him.

Jim Wallis, editor of the evangelical magazine Sojourners, in an interview connected with the PBS show Frontline episode titled "The Jesus Factor," recalls this meeting with President-elect Bush:
"…I'm often asked what I think about the faith of the President George W. Bush. I think it is sincere. I think it's very real. I think it's deeply held. I met the president when he was president-elect at a meeting in Austin. He spoke of his faith. He spoke of his desire for a compassionate conservatism, for a faith-based initiative that would do something for poor people. Afterwards, [when] he was talking to us, George W. took me aside and said, "Jim, I don't understand poor people. I don't live, never lived around poor people. I don't know [how] poor people think. Frankly, I'm a white Republican guy who just doesn't get it. But I'd like to. How do I get it? How do I understand?"

I said, "You need to listen to poor people, and people who work and live with poor people." In the inaugural address, which talked more about poverty than any inaugural in years, he said, "We have to listen. Most of us don't understand poverty," he said. "We have to listen to those who do..."
Wallis goes on to say:
"...Then Sept. 11 came. I think his role changed dramatically, his notion of himself and his place in history, and he became commander in chief of the war on terrorism. The self-help Methodist became now almost a messianic American Calvinist, speaking of the mission of America, and even of his perhaps divine appointment to be president at a time such as this..."
So President-elect Bush's concern for those bringing up the rear of the economic spectrum may have actually been sincere at that point in time. His push then and his funding now of faith-based initiatives could be well-intentioned.

But that begs the question why highly respected John J. DiIulio Jr., the first head of the White House Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives, departed the position six months after accepting it? DiIulio created an uproar for stating (but later retracting) this in a January, 2003, Esquire Magazine article:

"There is no precedent in any modern White House for what is going on in this one: a complete lack of a policy apparatus. What you've got is everything, and I mean everything, being run by the political arm. It's the reign of the Mayberry Machiavellis."
David Kuo, a deputy director of the office, departed later saying in this February, 2005, Beliefnet article:
"From tax cuts to Medicare, the White House gets what the White House really wants...the White House never really wanted the 'poor people stuff,' "
However, Kuo does perplexingly state in the same Beliefnet article that he believes President Bush is devout:
"...No one who knows him even a tiny bit doubts the sincerity and compassion of his heart..."
Prior to entering Harvard Business School, George  Bush worked with youth at Project PULL in inner-city Houston. There are disputed accounts on how and why this came to be and exactly what Bush's role was but in this October 22, 2004 Meg Laughlin/Knight Ridder article his work is described:
"...All agree Bush, who was 26 at the time, connected well with the teens, many of whom had been expelled from school..."
In a presidential campaign video titled "A Charge To Keep," President Bush says his efforts with Project PULL:
"gave him a glimpse of a world I had never seen. It was tragic, heartbreaking, and uplifting, all at the same time. I saw a lot of poverty. I also saw bad choices: drugs, alcohol abuse, men who had fathered children and walked away, leaving single mothers struggling to raise children on their own. I saw children who could not read and were way behind in school. I also saw good and decent people working to try to help lift these kids out of their terrible circumstances."
Obviously, the purpose of the video was to enhance Bush's image and presidential prospects but there is no doubt he got a personal look into the lives of people who cannot use name or familial connections to stabilize or enhance their lives.

One of his Harvard Business School professors,
Yoshi Tsurumi, has but harsh words in describing his former student. In a September 16, 2004, Mary Jacoby-written Salon article, is this:
"In 1973, as the oil and energy crisis raged, Tsurumi led a discussion on whether government should assist retirees and other people on fixed incomes with heating costs. Bush, he recalled, "made this ridiculous statement and when I asked him to explain, he said, 'The government doesn't have to help poor people -- because they are lazy.' I said, 'Well, could you explain that assumption?' Not only could he not explain it, he started backtracking on it, saying, 'No, I didn't say that...'"
...Bush once sneered at Tsurumi for showing the film "The Grapes of Wrath," based on John Steinbeck's novel of the Depression. "We were in a discussion of the New Deal, and he called Franklin Roosevelt's policies 'socialism.' He denounced labor unions, the Securities and Exchange Commission, Medicare, Social Security, you name it. He denounced the civil rights movement as socialism. To him, socialism and communism were the same thing. And when challenged to explain his prejudice, he could not defend his argument, either ideologically, polemically or academically."

Students who challenged and embarrassed Bush in class would then become the subject of a whispering campaign by him, Tsurumi said. "In class, he couldn't challenge them. But after class, he sometimes came up to me in the hallway and started bad-mouthing those students who had challenged him. He would complain that someone was drinking too much. It was innuendo and lies. So that's how I knew, behind his smile and his smirk, that he was a very insecure, cunning and vengeful guy..."
Tsurumi adds in the same article:
"I used to chat up a number of students when we were walking back to class," Tsurumi said. "Here was Bush, wearing a Texas Guard bomber jacket, and the draft was the No. 1 topic in those days. And I said, 'George, what did you do with the draft?' He said, 'Well, I got into the Texas Air National Guard.' And I said, 'Lucky you. I understand there is a long waiting list for it. How'd you get in?' When he told me, he didn't seem ashamed or embarrassed. He thought he was entitled to all kinds of privileges and special deals. He was not the only one trying to twist all their connections to avoid Vietnam. But then, he was fanatically for the war."
Prior to Harvard Business School, the Yale-attending George Bush rejected what he called the snobbery and elitism exhibited by many of his fellow students, especially the anti-war protestors. He thought it presumptuous that they felt they could change society which makes his current clarion calls for freedom and democracy throughout the world so confusing. Curiously, his disdain for his fellow Yalies didn't prevent him from joining the extremely elite and hyper-secretive Skull and Bones sect while at Yale.

Then, upon leaving Harvard Business School, George Bush leaned on the many upper crust connections enjoyed by the Bush family and those from his membership in Skull & Bones.

In a May, 2000, Alexandra Robbins-written article in The Atlantic, it is explained about how Bush's Arbusto enterprise came to be:
"...In 1977, when Bush formed Arbusto Energy, his first company, he once again applied to Skull and Bones for financial aid. With assistance from his uncle Jonathan Bush (Bones '53), he lined up $565,000 from twenty-eight investors. One of them contributed $93,000 -- the California venture capitalist William H. Draper III (Bones '50)..."
From the UNINFO.STATE.GOV official U.S. government web site link comes this:
He (Bush) formed a company called Arbusto (Spanish for "bush") Energy, later changed to Bush Exploration, but things did not go well. Oil prices began falling in the early 1980s, making it difficult for the new company to operate. In 1984, Bush decided to merge his company with another small exploration firm and became president of the new company, called Spectrum 7. In 1986, a larger company, Harken Energy Corporation, bought the small company.
The lucre lure of the Bush name and family connections are described further in a July 30, 1999 George Lardner Jr. and Lois Romano-written Washington Post article featuring background on George Bush's oil dealings:
"...The roster of prominent partners in Bush's oil ventures could have been extracted from a business world's who's who: drugstore magnate and onetime New York Republican gubernatorial candidate Lewis Lehrman and Lehrman family trusts ($140,500 over a three-year period); George L. Ball, then head of E.F. Hutton Inc., a New York stock brokerage ($100,000); George L. Ohrstrom, head of a New York investment management company and scion of one of Virginia's richest families ($100,000); California venture capitalist William H. Draper III ($93,000); and John D. Macomber, chief executive of the Celanese Corp. and an old Yale friend of Jonathan's ($79,500). Draper became president of the Export-Import Bank under President Ronald Reagan and Macomber held the same post under President George Bush..."
Oil drilling never returned much money to the investors, although tax write offs helped ease some of the financial pain and as Harken eventually bought out Bush's Spectrum 7 company, Robert Trigaux wrote this in his July 21, 2002, article in the St. Petersburg Times:
"...As part of the Spectrum buyout, Bush received Harken stock and was named a Harken director and paid consultant. He also gained membership in a group of Harken officials who could exercise options to buy company stock at a 40 percent discount, an unusual perk. Bush later received two low-interest loans from the company -- a corporate practice Bush now says should be stopped -- that were worth $180,375 by 1992.

It wasn't Bush's oil expertise that earned him these financial gains. Harken viewed Bush's famous name as an important asset. "It's obvious why they kept George Bush," Harken founder Phil Kendrick has been quoted as saying. "Just the fact that he's there gives them credibility."

Harken directors believed having "George's name there would be a big help to them," said Spectrum 7's former president, Paul Rea..."
The same article describes George Bush's next business venture into major league baseball:
"...In 1988, Cincinnati investor DeWitt called Bush to tell him that aging oil executive Eddie Chiles, the owner of the Texas Rangers and a Bush family friend since the 1950s, was looking for a buyer. Bush and DeWitt, passionate baseball fans, assembled an investor group.

At first, the group lacked deep pockets and enough local Texas participants to please Major League Baseball commissioner Peter Ueberroth. To ensure the Rangers stayed in Texas, and to bolster a pet project of the oldest son of the new U.S. president, Ueberroth recruited Fort Worth financier Richard E. Rainwater, the former hotshot money manager for the billionaire Bass brothers, to take charge.

Rainwater agreed to invest millions, but only after his trusted associate, Edward "Rusty" Rose, was installed as general managing partner. With new money, the group bought the Rangers from Chiles for $86-million.

Though Bush scraped together only $606,000 to invest, he was made a managing partner. The Rangers investors tagged Bush, with his now-famous name, to serve as the group's face to the public..."
Trigaux's article concludes with this remarkable quote:
"...Said Bush, in a favorite line about his wheeling-and-dealing era in private business: "I was a pit bull on the pant leg of opportunity."
Reporters Michael Kranish and John Aloysius Farrell n a July 12, 2002 article in the Boston Globe, reprinted at the CommonDreams.org provides another take on George Bush's entry into the big leagues:
"...Bush was hardly a big financial player. He needed $606,000 to become a co-owner - a small sum by baseball standards. But he could come up with only $106,000, so he borrowed another $500,000 from a bank at which he was a director. That gave him a 1.8 percent ownership in the club. The other owners did Bush an enormous favor, deciding to up his stake to nearly 12 percent. This was bonanza for Bush, giving him his first real test of Texas-sized financial success. Overnight, Bush was in a position to become a very wealthy man. The purchase took place at a time when Bush's father was president, and some of the other co-owners of the Rangers were major backers of then-President Bush, including Fred Malek and billionaire investor Richard Rainwater.

The success of the Rangers deal was assured by a tax increase. Bush, who would later emulate his father's ''no new taxes'' mantra in politics, pushed hard for a sales tax hike to help pay for the construction of the new ballpark at Arlington. To increase pressure for the tax hike, Bush and his fellow investors became one in a long line of baseball ownership teams to threaten to move the club out of town unless the public paid for a new stadium. The strategy worked, the sales tax was increased, and owners profited substantially.

All of that enabled the Rangers ownership team to sell the club later for three times the original price. But for Bush, the deal was even sweeter because his ownership stake had been increased from 1.8 percent to nearly 12 percent. Having invested $606,000, Bush received shares worth $14.9 million..".
The article ends with this quote:
"...In an interview in 1999 about his days at Harvard Business School, Bush recalled his most memorable course. ''I can remember taking an accounting course that was really interesting,'' Bush said. ''I began to see the tools of capitalism.''
So George Bush sees himself as a self made man. Such a description might carry greater gravitas if he traded on his surname and was unaided by Skull and Bones privileges.

And that takes us back to President Bush's forays into dismantling financial safety nets while simultaneously exhorting Americans to take on greater and greater risk in their respective economic futures.

Alas, if we could all profit so handsomely from our birth names and family web, such might not be a bad deal.

But
President Bush either doesn't want to know or doesn't care that the vast majority of American citizens do not have the wherewithal, the means and resources so easily accessible to him, to imitate his self-described "'pit bull on the pant leg of opportunity." We cannot fall back on generous family and friends or obtain cushy loans to bail us out of any faulty monetary maneuvers and mistakes.

At times in his life, it appears George Bush's heart may have been in the right place in wanting to learn more about the middle and lower economic classes. But such will got steamrollered by the who and what with which he has chosen to surround, insulate and isolate himself.

So, President Bush, cut as much brush as the photo-ops allow, handpick the audiences for your events, strut about on as many stages as you choose but do not pretend to speak for us. Do not fictionalize your concern for the vast majority of people in this country.

Hands off our ONLY safety nets.

You're not now nor have you ever been one of us.

 
top

RSS feed link RSS feed

Recent Posts My Best Blogs Archives Favorite Quotes Links Contact